Stephanie Mills Recalls Harsh Criticism During Her Broadway Debut as Original Dorothy in The Wiz: “Too Short, Too Ugly.”
In a remarkable documentary titled *It’s Dorothy!*, singer and actress Stephanie Mills reflects on her journey as the original Dorothy in the Broadway sensation *The Wiz*, which premiered in 1975. At just 17 years old, Mills stepped into a role that carried both immense prestige and daunting expectations. This was not merely a role in a musical; it was a reimagining of the classic journey first brought to life by Judy Garland in the beloved film *The Wizard of Oz*.
Despite the massive success of *The Wiz*, which won seven Tony Awards and made substantial strides in terms of Black representation on Broadway, Mills experienced a wave of harsh criticism. Several reviews targeted her physical attributes, labeling her as “too short” and “ugly.” One particularly scathing comment suggested that Garland should have “gotten out of her grave and slapped me.” This scrutiny highlights the intense pressure young performers face when stepping into iconic roles, especially in productions that seek to redefine cultural narratives.
A Deep Dive into *The Wiz*’s Cultural Significance
The documentary, celebrating the 125th anniversary of L. Frank Baum’s *The Wonderful Wizard of Oz*, includes poignant interviews with various artists, such as Ashanti and Lena Waithe, who share insights on the significance of the character of Dorothy. Directed by Jeffrey McHale, *It’s Dorothy!* emphasizes how Dorothy’s adventures resonate with anyone who has felt like an outsider, showcasing the timeless and universal themes of identity and belonging.
Not only did Mills face external criticism, but her journey underscores a pivotal shift in Broadway history. *The Wiz* was one of the first notable adaptations of a classic American story featuring a predominantly Black cast. Producer Ken Harper articulated the profound impact of representation, noting that the universal themes within the story strongly connect with audiences of all backgrounds.
Overcoming Criticism and Carving a Successful Career
Despite the negativity surrounding her Broadway debut, Mills went on to achieve incredible success in her music career, celebrated for hits such as “Never Knew Love Like This Before.” Now at the vibrant age of 68, Mills continues to honor her legacy by performing and connecting with fans. She recently embarked on a tour alongside music legends such as Gladys Knight, Patti LaBelle, and Chaka Khan, showcasing her enduring talent and passion for the arts.
Mills looks back on her time in *The Wiz* with pride, recognizing the impact of her role and the ongoing significance of Dorothy’s story. Dorothy’s journey remains an inspiring tale for countless individuals, reminding them of the importance of resilience and self-acceptance, regardless of society’s perceptions. The documentary *It’s Dorothy!* premiered at the Tribeca Festival, celebrating the lasting legacy of this cherished narrative and the diverse voices that continue to enrich its heritage.
Conclusion
Stephanie Mills’s reflections on her challenging yet transformative experiences as Dorothy in *The Wiz* serve as a powerful reminder of the significance of representation and resilience in the performing arts. Her journey inspires all of us to embrace our unique narratives. To explore more about Mills and her impactful story, be sure to catch the documentary *It’s Dorothy!* and celebrate the enduring legacy of this beloved character.
